A frame-by-frame review of André's 9-iron swing from the October 28 session at Mariners Point, filmed down-the-line from behind the hands, with the full ball-flight readout from the range screen. It's the first 9-iron report. It uses the new reference frame (grid, center lines, diagonals, depth rays, cap, waist and tush lines) and closes with simple next steps.
Bottom line: a solid first 9-iron. 117 yards total, 116 carry and 92.2 mph of ball speed, which is right at the LPGA Tour 9-iron average (93 mph). The flight shape also sits on the LPGA numbers: a 78 ft (26 yd) apex and a 47° landing angle, with only 6 ft of curve to the left. Carry is 3 yards short of the LPGA average (119) and 32 short of the PGA Tour average (148), and most of that gap is ball speed. This is the first 9-iron report, so these numbers are the baseline ★ for the club.
The swing has two clear strengths: the hips stayed back (the rear of the hips stayed within ~0.2 in of the tush line at impact) and the hands returned to their address spot (within ~0.7 in). Two things to work on: the head is about 6 in lower at impact, and the tempo is very slow on the way back. The backswing took ~1.23 s against a ~0.20 s downswing, a ratio of about 6.2:1 against the Tour's 3:1.
Hips stay back (~0.2 in off the tush line), hands return within ~0.7 in of address, and ball speed of 92.2 mph matches the LPGA average.
The head is ~6 in lower at impact and the hips rise ~1.8 in. Keep the cap near its address line so the low point stays steady.
The backswing takes ~1.23 s against a ~0.20 s downswing. The goal is a backswing of about 0.6 s, with the same quick downswing, for about 3:1.
| Metric | André (Oct 28) | LPGA Tour avg | PGA Tour avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ball speed | 92.2 mph ★ | 93 mph | 109 mph |
| Club speed (estimated) | ~66-67 mph | 72 mph | 85 mph |
| Carry | 116 yds ★ | 119 yds | 148 yds |
| Flat carry | 115 yds | — | — |
| Total | 117 yds ★ | — | — |
| Launch angle | 27° | 23.9° | 20.4° |
| Apex | 78 ft (26 yds) | 26 yds | 30 yds |
| Landing angle | 47° | 47° | 51° |
| Curve | 6 ft left | — | — |
| Hang time | 5.2 s | — | — |
| Proximity | 73 ft | — | — |
★ = first report for this club, so it sets the baseline. The curve direction is read from the arrows on the screen (the left arrow is bright, the right one dimmed). Club speed isn't on the screen: at a typical 9-iron smash of ~1.38-1.40, 92.2 mph of ball speed means about 66-67 mph of club speed, which is estimated. The video was filmed at 30 frames per second, so the ball could not be followed after impact. Slow motion (120 or 240 fps) would give the start direction.
What it means: the flight is a good, normal 9-iron: launch is 3° above the LPGA average, yet the apex and landing angle match it. The ball landed steeply and stopped quickly, with only 1 yard of roll (117 total vs 116 carry). The gap to the PGA Tour carry (32 yds) comes mostly from speed: ball speed is 17 mph lower (92 vs 109), and the estimated club speed is about 18-19 mph lower. Against the LPGA average, carry is only 3 yards short.
30 frames per second, so each time is accurate to about ±0.03 s. The backswing starts at ~32.00 s (frame 210), the top is at 33.23 s, and impact is at about 33.43 s.
| Group | Backswing | Downswing | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| André (9-iron, Oct 28) | ~1.23 s | ~0.20 s | ~6.2:1 |
| André (3-wood, Oct 24) | ~0.50 s | ~0.30 s | ~1.7:1 |
| PGA Tour (Tour Tempo, "24/8") | ~0.80 s | ~0.27 s | 3:1 |
Tour figure: John Novosel, Tour Tempo. One frame either way on the downswing moves the ratio between ~5.3:1 and ~7.2:1. The takeaway frame (226) comes ~0.5 s after the backswing began, and the hands had moved only ~1 in by then.
What it means: the downswing (~0.20 s) is quick and fine for a short iron. The slow part is the backswing, and most of the extra time goes into a very gradual start. This is the opposite of the 3-wood on Oct 24, which was rushed on the way back. A backswing near 0.6 s would put the ratio close to the Tour's 3:1.
Nine key positions, filmed down-the-line from behind the hands. The target is straight into the picture.
Photos are numbered in the order they happen in the swing. The frames follow the standard swing positions.
| Measure (vs address) | Top | Impact | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Head, down | ~4 in | ~6 in | Fix dip starts early in the backswing |
| Head, toward the ball line | ~3 in | ~3 in | Watch see depth note |
| Hips, toward the ball | ~0.7 in (away) | ~0 in | Good stay back |
| Hips vs tush line | — | ~0.2 in | Good stay on the line |
| Hips, up (waist height) | ~0.4 in | ~1.8 in | Watch slight stand-up |
| Hands vs address | — | ~0.7 in | Good back to the same spot |
| Shoulder turn (est.) | ~85° | ~15° open | Info visual estimate, ±10-15° |
| Hip turn (est.) | ~40° | ~35° open | Info hips lead the shoulders |
| X-factor at the top (est.) | ~45° | — | Info healthy gap between shoulders and hips |
| Tempo (back : down) | — | ~6.2:1 | Watch very slow backswing |
Depth note: from behind, the head's ~3 in shift sits partly along the depth rays, so it is a mix of "toward the ball" and "toward the target". One camera can't split the two, and the vanishing point comes from a single stick. A face-on clip of the next swing will settle it (see the last section).
| Club (best report) | Total | Carry | Ball speed | Launch | Curve |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5-Iron · Oct 2 | 169 yds | 159 yds | 108 mph | 19° | 20 ft |
| 6-Iron · Oct 14 | 150 yds | 146 yds | 107 mph | 20° | 17 ft right |
| 7-Iron · Oct 14 | 147 yds | 144 yds | 104 mph | 22° | 0 ft |
| 9-Iron · Oct 28 | 117 yds | 116 yds | 92.2 mph | 27° | 6 ft left |
Heads-up: the 9-iron carries 28 yards less than the 7-iron (116 vs 144) with 12 mph less ball speed. The 8-iron has no report yet and would sit between them, at about 14 yards per step. The gap that stands out is higher up: the 6-iron and 7-iron are only 2 yards apart in carry (146 vs 144), so that pair is worth a second look in later reports.
Confidence: high on ball flight (range screen) and on timing (measured frame by frame, ±0.03 s). Moderate on head and hip distances (grid scaled from body size, ±1 inch, and the vanishing point comes from one stick). Low on shoulder and hip angles (visual, ±10-15°), on the toward-ball vs toward-target split (needs a second angle) and on the club read from the sole (logged as the 9-Iron).
Same camera spot. Keep the top of the cap near the white address line until the ball is gone, for 10 balls.
Feel: "chest over the ball, knees keep their flex." A steadier head helps the hips stop rising.
Count "one-two-three" on the way back and "four" on the way down, for 5 balls. Start the takeaway right away, without waiting.
Aim for a backswing near 0.6 s with the same quick ~0.20 s downswing, which is about 3:1.
Film 5 balls from the same spot and check that the belt stays close to the dashed waist line through impact.
Hips rose ~1.8 in at impact. Staying level keeps the low point steady.
Whatever he did with the hips on Oct 28, keep it. The back pockets stay near the tush line through impact.
Hips stayed within ~0.2 in of the line, and the hands came back within ~0.7 in.
Next capture: (1) the same down-the-line spot with two target-line sticks, (2) a face-on clip at chest height, square to the feet stick, (3) the club sole held steady and close to the camera, with the club said out loud, (4) slow motion (120 or 240 fps) so the ball can be followed, (5) 3-5 balls for an average, and (6) André's height, to lock the grid scale.